metaphysics
-
The Deactionary: A glossary of terms from Terrence Deacon’s ‘Incomplete Nature’
Terrence W. Deacon’s 2012 book Incomplete Nature is a bold attempt to conceptualize the emergence of life and mind using a consistent ‘physicalist’ framework. I put the term ‘physicalist’ in scare-quotes because one of the appealing quirks of the book — and perhaps one that isn’t given enough attention despite a length of 500+ pages…
-
Why is the Hard Problem of Consciousness so Hard? Intentionality.
Someone I know sent me some material related to their research on consciousness, asking for some feedback. What follows is an edited version of what I wrote to them. Solving the easy problem of consciousness — by explaining the causes and neural correlates of particular conscious experiences — is challenging but at least conceivable. This…
-
What is emergence, and why should we care about it?
Emergence occurs when there is a conceptual discontinuity between two descriptions targeting the same phenomenon. This does not mean that emergence is a purely subjective phenomenon — only that scientific ‘double coverage’ may be a good place to look for emergent phenomena. For example, in the case of starling murmuration, there is an aggregate description…
-
Is reality continuous or discrete?
Reality is whatever it is… only our models of it can be considered continuous or discrete (or true, or false, or useful). I say this like it’s obvious, but it’s a potentially controversial opinion. 🙂 People have a strong tendency to confuse the map with the territory. So a very successful theory becomes synonymous with reality itself.…
-
Is “nothing” a thing, or is there no such thing as “nothing”?
Perhaps we have to start by asking what a “thing” is. Let’s try the following definition: a thing has the attribute of location in space and time. Further, we might conclude that in order to locate something, we must have a sense of its extent in space and time: its boundaries. This definition of “thing” is handy because…